Is ADHD Over-diagnosed? ADHD Diagnosis, Trauma, and Getting Started with Dr. J. Russell Ramsay

It’s ADHD Awareness Month. Book your free ‘good fit’ coaching session with Dave today.

Dr. J. Russell Ramsay is a psychologist specializing in the assessment and psychosocial treatment of adult ADHD. He has lectured internationally and is widely published. He has written six books on adult ADHD, including his most recent, Once I Get Started : The Adult ADHD Program for Turning Your Intentions into Actions. Dr. Ramsay is a CHADD Hall of Fame inductee.

By his own account, he had no business starting an ADHD program. Penn asked him to, and he's been at it ever since.

Russ returns to Wise Squirrels since our first interview to take on the loudest talking points about ADHD right now, and he brings the data:

ADHD isn't overdiagnosed. It's catching up. ADHD has been the number two adult psychiatric diagnosis in the U.S. for twenty years, sitting between anxiety and depression. In the CDC's 2024 data, about half of adults with ADHD were first diagnosed as adults. Russ reads the recent rise as a correction after decades of people being missed.

Most clinicians were never trained in it. Russ compares it to a family doctor saying diabetes wasn't covered in medical school. That gap is why so many adults get treated for anxiety or depression while the ADHD underneath goes unnoticed.

Not environmentally caused, but environmentally bound. ADHD is about goodness of fit with your surroundings. The best job for someone with ADHD is whatever you find interesting that you can do, and yes, that includes accountants who love numbers.

ADHD, trauma, or both? Russ explains how a careful clinician separates ADHD from trauma, anxiety, depression, bipolar disorder, and OCD. Two questions do most of the work: when did it start, and what's still there when the other condition is quiet?

The trauma claim. Dave argues that celebrity doctors like Gabor Maté, who keep saying trauma causes ADHD, have moved from misinformation to disinformation. Russ is more measured, but agrees the claim is misleading.

The "medication stops working" myth. The largest treatment study of children with ADHD gets cited as proof that medication fades. Russ explains what happened: the study ended, and so did the free treatment. It's like taking away someone's gym membership and concluding that exercise doesn't work.

ADHD IS AN UNCERTAINTY GENERATOR

Russ's explanation for why ADHD and anxiety travel together may be the most useful idea in the episode. Anxiety feeds on uncertainty, and ADHD produces it daily: you know you can do the thing, but you don't know if you will do it when you intend to. He calls that consistent inconsistency a central feature of ADHD.

That is also where the book title comes from. For years Russ told clients that if he ever wrote a popular book, he'd call it Once I Get Started. Dave shares his Reverse Pomodoro timer and his idea of a minimum viable action, and Russ offers his own question: what's the smallest step that moves you from not doing to doing? As he puts it, "Those five minutes have to come from somewhere."

Also in this episode:

Why women are diagnosed later and what happens when a parent recognizes themselves in their child's evaluation, ADHD through postpartum, perimenopause, and menopause, what the pandemic did to diagnosis rates, where AuDHD fits and what the DSM-5 changed, how you can have eight of eighteen symptoms and still not qualify, and the time Dave got in trouble at his kids' school for doing magic tricks at lunch.

Resources mentioned

Find Russ and Once I Get Started at cbt4adhd.com.

Sharing is caring

Wise Squirrels is Sponsored by Futureforth.

Dave

🇨🇦+🇮🇪=🇺🇸

https://davedelaney.me
Next
Next

Dr. Stephen Faraone: What the Evidence Actually Says About ADHD.